Apparently there actually was an outcry (well, as much of an outcry as 'good guys' like Israel or the US ever have to face for anything they do) over the US using WP in Iraq. Depleted uranium too, of course, but there was a kerfuffle over the use of WP in their attack on Fallujah (and no, I'm not confusing this with Saddam Hussein's alleged massacres in Fallujah years before). The US military first said they used WP just for screening smoke, the way BorderC explained. Then they said they fired it to provide illumination at night (which seems to me to be an odd use for a smoke device, but maybe BorderC can tell us more about this).
Ultimately when the UK newspaper The Independent presented evidence that they had used it for its toxic, anti-personnel properties, the US military took back its previous stories and said "well, yes, but we only targeted fighters with it." From the way we can see the stuff
B
BorderC (Little Upsilon)
All worlds
If they are using WP on civilians, then yes, that's bad. But, how is it different than HE?
It's as precise as any indirect projectile is. Moreso now that it is computerized. It doesn't rain on people... it's a cloud. That's why it can be used for screening. Most of it goes up in the air and eventually dissipates. Do you think they would prefer HE instead?
And we never used WP for illumination. There are illumination rounds for that. Though, there are still reasons to screen at night. Especially in the desert.
V
Váli (Fearless Blue)
All worlds
Depleted uranium is used to penertrate armoured vehicles, as Hamas dont have these I pressume the isrealis wont use any/many.
Depleted uranium does not make bangs bigger, it is a very dense material that is better able to penertrate armour than steel. They may well use it to attack bunkers etc.
Terrorist use child to carry suicide bomb...no complaints...israeli kills a child and we have screams of complaint.
Both sides are of course wrong but please dont forget hamas etc have little reguard for life and are more than able to parade dead children for the sake of good PR and then go and strap a bomb to one.
My saving israel uses too much force, I mean the US army I hope would not target the enemy with indirct shell if they are next to a school but use more precise force such as a sniper..the isralis will however just bomb them and civilian casualites are excepted. they have become desensitised to war.
Hamas however will deliberaly target
T
The Grand Poobah (Golden Rainbow)
All worlds
prophecy prevents peace. Christians and Muslims are so wrapped up in there dogmatic belief system that they forget the truths. In both religions, killing of one's own kind is explicetely shunned. Thus, there are other evils at play. Greed, ignorance, hatred and suffering. Untill there is a social maturation, war will never end.
G
Gaius Brutus (Little Upsilon)
All worlds
Its all Hamas fault because they decided to attack Israel and publicly told everyone about it. Soooo duh none of this is Israels fault. Yall must of forgot in war there are no rules. The citizens of Gaza new that Hamas was gonna attack Israel they could of left then before the attacks dduuuhhhhhhhh!!!!!
I appluad Israel for their decision to invade. They have taken alot of crap from Palestians in the area. Especially back in 1960. I can't wait until Obama becomes the official president cause when he does and decides to send Marines out there to help Israel, I'll be one of the first to sign up.
FYI, when God sent out his armies to conquere a city they would either burn the whole city to the ground with everyone still inside burning to death.
THERES NO SUCH THING AS MERCY IN WAR!!!!!
IF YOU DON"T WANT TO DIE THEN GET OUT OF THE WAY!!!
MOVING FROM ONE PLACE TO THE OTHER DOESN'T ANY MONEY ALL YOU NEED IS Y
A
Almohad117 (White Giant)
All worlds
"Terrorists use children to carry suicide bombs - no complaint. Israelis kill a child and we have screams of complaint."
???? The whole world denounces Hamas terror. It's Israeli terror that passes with little or no comment. It's only finally getting a bit of attention right now because they've really outdone themselves in brutality and bloodshed. (A UN school - keep up the good work guys!)
Man, the world condemns Hamas even for stuff it does NOT do, for example breaking the recent ceasefire. Israel broke it, not Hamas. But Israel's PR machine is so deeply entrenched, especially in the US where the Israeli view dominates all the media, that you never hear anyone articulate this simple truth.
On BBC's "HardTalk" today, for example, they "grilled" the Israeli ambassador to the UK. The host did manage to give the guy a genuinely hard time, which was nice to see, but he made no com
J
Johanas Bilderburg (Little Upsilon)
All worlds
Bibab Schmeagol? She is a topless dancer I think...
Anyway I went and had a great day working outdoors and it looks like you gentlemen had a great Left wing mutual masturbation session. Anything solved? No? I am shocked!
I expected a grand peace plan when I returned.
G
Gaius Brutus (Little Upsilon)
All worlds
The only way Hamas will stop firing rockets in Israel is if THERE IS NO ISRAEL!!!
Don't yall get it. Its in the Quaran, ALL MUSLIMS WANT ISRAEL TO BE GONE. NOT ONLY THAT BUT ALL JEWS MUST DIE ALSO. THATS WHAT THE QUARAN TEACHES. If I'm not mistaken.
Without religion why are we alive then? We didn't just appeared hear.
V
Váli (Fearless Blue)
All worlds
The grand peace plan as you requested....
1) Al and I shall agree to differ.
2) Al will deactivate the suicide bombing kids and send them back to school.
3) I will stop bombing said schools to take out the future bomber recruits.
4) Al shall research depleted uranium and discover its very limited radioactivity.
5) Al shall realise Hamas seeks Israels distruction and needs no excuse to attack israel. Its mere existance is reason enough.
6) I shall except some israelis are in fact Hamas agents that have infiltrated the IDF with the aim of provocing the conflict via indiscriminate attacks on Gaza.
7) Gaius brutus enters reconditioning to deprogramme his anti islamic views.
8) Johanas posts video of bibab schmeagol so we can assess the validity of her pressumed occupation.
A
Almohad117 (White Giant)
All worlds
<!-Quote-!>Quote:Its all Hamas fault because they decided to attack Israel and publicly told everyone about it. Soooo duh none of this is Israels fault.<!-/Quote-!>
I honestly thought you were being sarcastic, GB, because that's such a load of bullshit...
All I can say is, another buddy for Farmer Bob and Vali!!
A
Almohad117 (White Giant)
All worlds
Bebop Schmeagol is a he, not a she. Take a walk on the wild side...
A
Almohad117 (White Giant)
All worlds
"It's in the Quran - all Muslims want Israel to be gone."
Man, this guy is gooood....!
A
Almohad117 (White Giant)
All worlds
"Very limited radioactivity" - whatever. Enough to generate cancer clusters around the sites where depleted uranium munitions were used, not only in Iraq but also in the Balkans.
Peace, man.
But no way am I sending my kiddies to school after what happened today.